← The Lunara Almanac

HISTORY · THE LUNARA ALMANAC

The strange history of pumpkin spice

Follow the flavor from eighteenth-century pumpkin recipes to premixed pantry spices and the autumn drinks that made the name familiar far beyond the pie.

Pumpkin spice usually combines cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, cloves, or some arrangement of those warm spices. The name describes seasonings used in pumpkin pie, so a pumpkin-spice product may contain the blend without containing pumpkin.

On a modern shelf, pumpkin spice can describe coffee, cereal, candles, dog treats, and objects no sensible person has tried to bake in a crust. The blend became a shorthand for autumn because it spent a very long time attached to a particular American dessert.

Before the little jar

Cooks built the flavor one spice at a time.

Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery, published in 1796 and often described as the first cookbook written by an American and published in the United States, included two recipes for “pompkin” pudding in pastry. One used mace, nutmeg, and ginger. The other used allspice and ginger.

Neither recipe called the combination “pumpkin spice.” The cook was expected to reach for separate ingredients and season to the recipe. The exact group varied, as household blends still do. What remained familiar was the pairing of rich pumpkin custard with spices that were already used across cakes, puddings, gingerbread, and holiday baking.

A twentieth-century shortcut

The recipe became a product.

By the early twentieth century, spice companies were selling pre-mixed blends for pumpkin pie. A 1930 newspaper advertisement preserved by the Library of Congress promoted mixed pumpkin pie spice, while McCormick dates its own blend to 1934. The familiar jar solved a plain kitchen problem: instead of buying and measuring several spices, a cook could shake in one mixture.

The blend was never completely fixed. McCormick’s current version lists cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and allspice. Other blends add cloves or mace, change the proportions, or leave one spice out. Recipes and brands use different combinations, so two jars with the same name can taste different.

From pie to season

Pumpkin pie spice became shorthand for an autumn flavor.

Pumpkin pie already belonged to fall harvest tables and Thanksgiving. A premixed jar strengthened the association by putting the name on a label. Food companies could then borrow the blend for cakes, cookies, drinks, and packaged goods without having to bring the pie along.

The ingredients helped. Cinnamon, ginger, and cloves are fragrant, noticeable, and strongly connected to baked food. They also arrive when stores and kitchens are shifting toward colder-weather routines. With repeated encounters each fall, the smell can become a calendar cue for someone who associates it with sweaters, shorter days, and a suspicious number of decorative gourds.

Then came the cup

An autumn flavor became an annual coffee-shop event.

Starbucks developed its Pumpkin Spice Latte in 2003, tested it in about one hundred stores, and rolled it out more widely the following year. The company describes the development process as tasting pumpkin pie with espresso to identify which flavors carried across. The finished drink used a spice profile built around cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg.

The drink gave that old pie association a new annual outing. People could pick it up on the way to work, and the company could announce its return each fall. A flavor that had spent generations in the pantry became a coffee-shop event, with the name soon appearing on products very far from the kitchen.

Try the history in a bowl

Smell the spices separately before mixing them.

Put a little cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, and clove in separate dishes. Notice which one smells most like the idea of “pumpkin spice” to you. Then combine a small pinch of each. The blend will probably smell more familiar than any one ingredient.

Notice which spice stands out in the mixture, then compare the ingredients with a pie recipe or a jar from your cupboard. Changing the proportions is one reason those familiar autumn flavors vary from kitchen to kitchen.

A FEW OF THE SOURCES BEHIND THIS PIECE

Read a little deeper

✦ CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION

I’d love to hear what you think.

Have you tried something similar, noticed something different, or found yourself wondering about a detail? Pick a question below, or bring your own.

  • What scent or flavor tells you autumn has arrived?
  • Have you encountered a surprising story about an everyday spice?

Leave a comment

Comments appear after review and are emailed privately to the site owner for moderation. Please avoid sharing children’s names or other private details. Adults only. Privacy policy.

Loading comments…

A choice about analytics

Optional analytics help us see which pages are useful. You can browse, download, and join the email list without them. Privacy policy.